Philodendron Propagation: Water vs Soil Comparison

Disclosure: As Amazon Associates we earn from qualifying purchases. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.

Please note that while we always strive to provide 100% up to date and accurate information, there is always the small possibility of error. Therefore, we advise conducting further research and due diligence before consuming any plants or exposing pets to anything mentioned on this site. Kindly refer to the full disclaimer for more details here.

Propagating philodendrons is a popular activity among houseplant enthusiasts, as it allows them to expand their collection or share their love for these beautiful plants with friends and family. The two main methods of propagating philodendrons are water and soil propagation. Each method has its unique advantages and drawbacks, which we will discuss in this article to help you choose the best option for your specific needs and preferences.

Water propagation is an attractive method for beginners because it allows you to witness the root development firsthand. Simply snip a healthy stem cutting and place it in a container of clean water, making sure the leaves don’t touch the water. Over time, roots will emerge, and you can then transfer the cutting to soil. On the other hand, soil propagation involves planting the stem cutting directly into moist potting soil. This method eliminates the need for the extra step of moving the cutting from water to soil once roots have formed, reducing the risk of shock to the plant.

Both water and soil propagation can be successful in growing new philodendron plants. The choice ultimately depends on your preferences, available resources, and comfort level with the propagation process. In the rest of this article, we will provide detailed information and practical tips for each method, ensuring that you have all the knowledge necessary to make an informed decision and successfully propagate your philodendron.

Philodendron Overview

Philodendron is a popular and versatile houseplant known for its attractive foliage and easy-to-grow nature. This diverse genus includes climbing and trailing varieties as well as more upright forms. They are relatively low-maintenance plants that can adapt well to various indoor conditions, making them a favorite among houseplant enthusiasts.

These attractive plants can thrive in a range of light conditions, but they generally prefer bright, indirect light. Maintaining consistent humidity levels and watering properly are also vital to keep your philodendron happy and healthy. Overwatering is one issue to watch out for, as it may cause root rot and other problems.

Philodendrons can be propagated either in water or soil, depending on your preference. Both methods yield successful results, allowing you to propagate cuttings for friends, family members, or personal use. Let’s briefly explore the advantages and techniques of each propagation method.

Water Propagation: This method involves placing a stem cutting with at least one node underwater in a glass or vase filled with clean water. The leaves should not be submerged, and the container should be kept in a bright, indirect light location. After some time, roots will start to grow from the node, making it ready to be transplanted into soil. The advantage of water propagation is that it allows you to visually monitor root growth.

Soil Propagation: For soil propagation, take a stem cutting with the lower leaves removed and plant it in a small container filled with well-draining potting soil. Keep the soil moist but not soggy, and place it in a warm, humid, and brightly lit area. After a few weeks, you can check for root development by gently tugging on your cutting. Resistance indicates successful rooting. New leaf growth is another sign that your cutting has rooted and is ready to grow into a new plant.

In summary, both water and soil propagation have their benefits and techniques, allowing you to choose the method that best fits your needs and preferences. Regardless of the method you choose, the final result will be a new, thriving philodendron plant that can add beauty and life to your indoor living space.

Propagation Methods

Philodendron plants can be propagated through two main methods: water propagation and soil propagation. Both techniques offer unique advantages and can result in healthy, thriving plants. Below, we will explore the details of each propagation method.

Water Propagation

Water propagation is a simple and popular method of propagating philodendrons. To propagate in water, follow these steps:

  1. Take a healthy stem cutting from the mother plant, ensuring it has several leaves and at least one node.
  2. Remove any leaves from the stem that would be submerged in water.
  3. Fill a glass or vase with clean water and place the cutting in it, making sure that at least one node is underwater but no leaves are.
  4. Place the glass in a bright spot with indirect light to promote root growth.

Remember to change the water every few days to avoid stagnation and maintain a healthy environment for the developing roots. Once the roots have grown to approximately two inches, your cutting is ready to be transplanted into soil.

Soil Propagation

Soil propagation is another effective method for growing philodendron plants. To propagate in soil, follow these steps:

  1. Take a healthy stem cutting from the mother plant, again with several leaves and at least one node.
  2. Remove any leaves from the stem that would be buried in the soil.
  3. Dip the cut end of the stem in rooting hormone, though this is optional.
  4. Place the cutting directly into moist potting soil, firming the soil around the stem to hold it in place.
  5. Make sure none of the leaves are buried or submerged in the soil.
  6. Place your container in a brightly lit spot with indirect sunlight, and keep the soil moist throughout the rooting process.

Both water and soil propagation methods are effective and can result in successful growth, so it’s up to the gardener’s preference which method to use. No matter which method you choose, provide proper care and attention to ensure the cutting develops into a healthy, thriving philodendron plant.

Comparing Water and Soil Propagation

Success Rates

Propagating a Philodendron plant can be done using both water and soil methods. Generally, water propagation is considered to have a slightly higher success rate, as it allows you to closely monitor root growth and control the level of moisture around the stem cutting. Soil propagation can also be successful, but some sources suggest sterilizing the soil to avoid any potential bacteria or rot issues.

Time to Root Formation

When it comes to the time required for root formation, water propagation is generally faster. In water, Philodendron cuttings will usually begin to show root growth within 1 to 2 weeks. Soil propagation, on the other hand, can take a longer time for roots to become established. This is because the cutting has to adjust to its new environment and expend energy to work its roots into the soil.

Growth Speed

The growth speed of Philodendron cuttings can differ depending on the propagation method used. Water-propagated cuttings might show quicker initial growth since the roots are already taking up water and nutrients efficiently. However, some sources indicate that soil-propagated cuttings may eventually catch up in terms of overall growth speed, as the plant adjusts to anchoring itself in the soil.

In summary, both water and soil propagation methods can be successful for Philodendron plants. However, water propagation tends to offer a slightly higher success rate, faster initial growth, and quicker root formation, while soil propagation might require extra care to avoid bacteria and rot issues. Ultimately, choosing the best method comes down to personal preference and the specific needs of your plant.

Pros and Cons

Benefits of Water Propagation

Water propagation is a popular method for rooting philodendron cuttings due to its simplicity and effectiveness. Some advantages of this method include:

  • Easier monitoring of root development, as you can visually observe the progress in clear water
  • Lower risk of stem or leaf rot, provided the water is changed regularly
  • No need for rooting hormone or additional growth mediums, making it an affordable option

This step-by-step guide demonstrates how straightforward it is to propagate philodendrons in water.

Drawbacks of Water Propagation

Despite its effectiveness, water propagation has some drawbacks:

  • Cuttings may take longer to root compared to soil propagation
  • Adaptation to soil, once rooted, can be challenging for the plant
  • Risk of contamination if water is not changed regularly or if the cutting is not clean

Benefits of Soil Propagation

Soil propagation is another useful method for propagating philodendron plants. Some benefits include:

  • Faster root development compared to water propagation
  • Easier transition for the plant, as it remains in its natural growing medium
  • Potential for diverse microbial activity, which can stimulate growth

This article provides detailed steps on how to propagate philodendron in soil.

Drawbacks of Soil Propagation

Nevertheless, soil propagation has its own disadvantages:

  • Risk of rot due to overwatering or poor soil drainage
  • Potential for bacterial or fungal contamination, especially if the soil is not sterilized
  • Difficulty in monitoring root development as it takes place underground

Overall, understanding the pros and cons of both water and soil propagation methods can help you decide which approach best suits your needs and preferences.

Factors Affecting Success

Type of Philodendron

There are several types of Philodendron plants, and the success of propagating them may vary depending on the species. For instance, some Philodendrons might root in water easier than in soil, while others might have better success in soil propagation. Research the specific type of Philodendron you have to learn its preferred propagation method.


The quality of the cuttings plays a significant role in the success of Philodendron propagation. For better results in both water and soil, consider using:

  • Healthy stem cuttings with at least one leaf
  • Aerial roots present on the cutting, if possible
  • A clean, sharp tool to make a diagonal cut
  • Optionally, rooting hormone to increase the chances of successful rooting

Plant Health

A healthy mother plant will produce healthier cuttings, leading to more successful propagations. Ensure the Philodendron you’re taking cuttings from is in good health by:

  • Regularly watering while allowing the top inch of soil to dry between waterings
  • Providing bright, indirect light
  • Monitoring for pests and diseases and addressing them as needed

Environmental Conditions

Environmental factors also play a role in the success of propagating Philodendrons. Regardless of whether you choose to propagate in water or soil, ensure the following conditions:

  • Maintain a consistent temperature in the 65°F-80°F range
  • High humidity levels to promote root growth
  • Consider using a self-watering pot for soil propagation to maintain an optimal moisture level

By keeping all these factors in mind and adjusting as needed, you can improve your chances of successful Philodendron propagation using either water or soil methods.


In summary, propagating philodendrons can be accomplished using two methods: water and soil. Both techniques offer advantages and share common steps, such as taking stem cuttings and selecting a bright, indirect light location for the cuttings to grow.

Water propagation is typically the simpler option, and results can be seen relatively quickly. Cuttings are placed in water with at least one node submerged, but leaves should remain above water. The simplicity of this method allows for easy monitoring of root development.

On the other hand, soil propagation involves planting the stem cuttings directly into a well-draining potting mix. This method provides a more stable environment for the emerging roots and may lead to stronger, more robust plants in the long run.

Ultimately, the choice between water and soil propagation depends on individual preferences and resources.

Key factors to consider when choosing a method are:

  • Visibility: Water propagation allows you to monitor root growth more easily.
  • Effort: Soil propagation may require more attention to ensure proper moisture and nutrient levels.
  • Plant Health: Soil-grown philodendrons might develop stronger root systems over time.

Regardless of the chosen method, remember to be patient and consistent in your care. Philodendrons are generally low-maintenance plants, and successful propagation can lead to a larger collection of these beautiful, heart-shaped foliage plants to enjoy or share with friends and family.

Helpful Video